Chemistry |
Lesson
9: Global warming – is it real? |
Curriculum
Key: |
AQA
12.6 |
|
Gateway
P1h, P2c |
Edexcel
Topic 7 |
Objective(s)
1.
Analyse graphs and interpret tables.
2. Select relevant scientific
evidence to support an opinion.
3. Work as part of a team.
|
Resources
needed
PowerPoint
presentation
Optional data-logging opportunity
– see guidance notes. |
Starter:
15
minutes PowerPoint
– ‘A Journey to Venus’
(Including a quick recap of the
Greenhouse Effect).
Students may be encouraged to
note the possible signs to support
the theory of global warming,
as shown in the PowerPoint. |
Teacher
input/assessment
Teacher-led
discussion (Note: the PowerPoint
activity has an audio track). |
Main
Activity 1: 5
minutes Split
class into groups of 3. Each group
is one of five roles. Students
read their brief and decide upon
the evidence that they may want
to find in the data to support
their argument. Teacher to prompt
with suggestions (see teaching
notes) |
Teacher
input / assessment
Teacher-led
(the teacher may read each role
to the class). |
Main
Activity 2: 25
minutes Students
analyse the data (suggest that
3 copies of all the data be laminated;
each group uses the small tracking
sheet to ensure that they have
seen everything). In groups, decide
upon the evidence that best supports
their group’s argument. Record
on the ‘Evidence Recorder’ sheet. |
Teacher
input / assessment
Teacher
guidance for each group may be
dependent upon ability. |
Plenary:
15
minutes Each
group presents their 3-6 statements
to the rest of the class.
(Then the teacher may discuss
the idea that all students had
the same evidence but reached
different conclusions dependant
upon their bias.).
Students are asked what they have
learned during the lesson. |
Teacher
input / assessment
Discussion
at the end. |
Learning
Outcomes: All
students must: work
as a group to produce 3-6 statements
that are supported by scientific
evidence. Most
students should: understand
that the same data can be used
to produce different conclusions.
Some
students could: analyse
the evidence that contradicts
their argument to look at ways
that it can be discredited/ignored
or explained. |
Key
Skills: Communication,
presentation skills
Key
words: aluminium,
smelting, environmental factors
Homework:
Write
their opinion on whether after
analysing the data they believe
the Greenhouse effect is real,
and whether the Kyoto agreement
will make a difference.
|
Differentiation:
More
able: should
choose appropriate graphs and
statistics to support their argument.
Are given a more challenging group
(eg MP).
Less
able: Interpret
graphs.
Are given an easier group such
as member of the public. |